i'm gonna put the list of my success rate as staff carvemage here
My Fire Kryst O'Boul made with a Fire Potion (High):
success : 30/71 -> 42%
A fire Wa Wabbit Staff made for Branowen from Cathar Knights with a Blazing Fire Potion (Medium):
success : 3/3 -> 100%
A fire Magus Bwork Staff made for Emanuel with a Fire Potion (High):
success : 1/8 -> 12%
A Fire Staff of the Feca's Follower made for Chibitofu with a Fire Potion (High):
Success 7/15 -> 47%
An Earth Yondanwa Staff made for Axar with an Earthquake Potion (High):
Success 2/2 -> 100%
Excellent Staff of Kings : Success 0/2 -> 0%
A Marie Aigue's Staff made for RamboPL with Fire Potion (High):
Success 3/18 -> 17%
Treestaff : Success 0/3 -> 0%
A Fire Abraknydi Vivitus made for Triffus with Fire Potion (High):
Success 3/5 -> 60%
An Aga Dou Staff with Fire Potion (High):
Success 0/1 -> 0%
A Grandpa Wabbit Staff
Success 1/1 -> 100%